"But that would be their call, not ours," Mantoloking Police Chief Stacy Ferris told the borough council in September, as Star News Group reported. "It's not our street."
She meant Herbert Street, which is a county road. Her answer also describes the whole holiday-traffic problem at the foot of the Mantoloking Bridge. Mantoloking can't decide the routes that send cars onto Barnegat Lane, can't decide what the county puts at the intersection, and can't change Route 35. The part it can work on, starting this fall and through the winter, is information. That means traffic counts, warning signs and a safer crossing for the people walking past the bridge. The rest depends on Ocean County, the state, and the companies that run navigation apps.
The Weekends That Started It
The issue reached the council at its July 21, 2026 meeting. According to the minutes, residents described congestion on Barnegat Lane over Memorial Day, the Fourth of July and Labor Day weekends as "recurring and increasingly hazardous." Drivers leaving Route 35 use the street as a bypass. Speakers said they couldn't get out of their own driveways on those weekends. They described cars speeding down narrow residential streets and drivers turning around in private driveways. Several pointed out that Barnegat Lane is narrower than other local streets, which makes the same traffic more dangerous there.
Chief Ferris agreed that holiday traffic has gotten worse. She said the Fourth of July weekend just past was the worst of her time as chief. Emergency services kept running through extra staffing and careful placement of officers, but the minutes say the delays were "substantial."
Council members also said the problem goes beyond Barnegat Lane and affects the whole barrier island. They wanted any fix to avoid simply pushing the cars onto the next street. Once that was the goal, it mattered a great deal who controls each possible fix.
The Levers, and Who Holds Them
The July and September minutes, along with the October Star News report, describe each option residents and officials raised. The table below shows who controls each one and where it stood in late October 2026.
| Option | Who decides | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|
| Changing GPS routing through local streets | Google and Waze; a state process runs through the Attorney General | Earlier borough requests to Google and Waze were denied. The borough attorney called the state process impractical for short holiday traffic peaks |
| Seasonal signal at Herbert Street and Barnegat Lane | Ocean County | The county isn't supporting it for now |
| Restricting a left turn at Barnegat Lane | The borough by ordinance, with county and state coordination if access to their roads changes | Under evaluation. Nothing adopted |
| Baseline traffic data around the bridge | Ocean County | Three cameras installed |
| Real-time electronic message boards | Mantoloking Police Department | One used over Labor Day. A more advanced sign is being priced to rent or buy |
| Pedestrian crossing at the base of the bridge | State grant | In process, as Star News reported in October |
| A traffic engineer to study the whole borough | The borough | Staff told in July to look into hiring one |
The first row explains the rest of the table. A resident at the July meeting brought up New Jersey's 2025 Safer App legislation as a way to limit GPS-directed traffic. The minutes record that Borough Attorney Cipriani explained what it actually allows. A town can ask for routing changes through the Attorney General, but only after collecting extensive traffic and emergency-response data. That makes it a poor fit for traffic that peaks on three weekends a year. The chief added that the borough had already asked Google and Waze directly and been turned down.
So the apps will probably keep sending holiday traffic toward Barnegat Lane next summer. Most of the rows below that one are ways of managing those cars once they arrive.
Two Left Turns, Two Different Proposals
Most of the attention has gone to the idea of restricting left turns. Two separate proposals have been discussed.
In July, residents proposed a temporary ordinance that would ban left turns onto Barnegat Lane just before and after major holidays. The goal was to keep through traffic out of the lane in the first place. The borough attorney said a restriction applying to every driver would hold up legally better than one that let only residents through. She added that any ordinance affecting traffic flow could still be challenged, and that changing access to county or state roads would require working with those agencies.
The county study runs the other direction. The September minutes say its three cameras around the bridge are collecting baseline data for a study that includes "the possibility of eliminating the left turn from Barnegat Lane onto the highway." That proposal deals with cars leaving the lane, not entering it.
Neither one has been adopted. In July, the mayor told staff to consider a temporary no-left-turn restriction as part of a broader traffic-engineering review, subject to legal review. Any turn rule that eventually shows up on a sign at the bridge will come out of that review and the county's data. The borough can't settle it on its own.
Why the Crosswalk Matters to the Signal Decision
The seasonal signal at Herbert Street and Barnegat Lane looks like the obvious fix. It was raised again in September. According to the minutes, the county "has previously indicated it would not support the proposal at this time, in part because of planned pedestrian improvements near the bridge." In remarks reported by Star News Group, Chief Ferris was more specific. The borough is "in the process of taking a state grant for the Hawk system at the bottom of the bridge for pedestrian crossing."
In the same report, the chief said "hundreds of people cross near the bridge daily," mostly Monday through Friday, many of them going to and from the yacht club. The Mantoloking Yacht Club is at 1224 Bay Avenue on Barnegat Bay. Ocean County also runs the Mantoloking Bridge Fishing Pier at 30 Mantoloking Road, a year-round park with a 70-foot pier, a boardwalk, a picnic area and lighted paths. The traffic coming off the bridge on a holiday Saturday passes the same spot where these walkers are crossing.
A HAWK is what the Federal Highway Administration calls a pedestrian hybrid beacon. It stays dark until someone on foot presses the call button. Then it runs a yellow-to-red sequence that tells drivers to slow down and stop while the person crosses. FHWA describes it as a middle option between a flashing beacon and a full pedestrian signal. It stops traffic outright, and it requires a marked crosswalk and a pedestrian countdown signal.
When nobody is crossing, a HAWK doesn't stop cars at all. A signal at Herbert and Barnegat would cycle all day, so the county may be reluctant to add one so close to the beacon. The minutes don't give the county's full reasoning. They tie its "no" to the planned crossing, and the Star News account gives the HAWK as one of the reasons for it. The chief said the borough could bring the signal up again with county engineers, and that the decision would still belong to the county.
What the Quiet Months Are For
That leaves the borough with information. Its first test came over Labor Day weekend. A single electronic message board went up, and according to Star News Group, residents' feedback was positive. Traffic backed up Saturday morning and afternoon, but the chief called conditions manageable. "Everything seemed to flow properly," she said.
The next sign would do more. Ferris described signage that gives real-time warnings about congestion and delays and suggests other routes. The department is pricing rentals and may buy one in the capital budget. Labor Day was the light test. Ferris said the real effect won't be clear until "the next Memorial Day and 4th of July when we attempt to do it again."
The county's cameras are collecting data right now, during the quietest stretch of the year on Barnegat Lane. A baseline needs ordinary days to compare against the holiday weekends, so November and January traffic counts as much as July. Here is what has to happen before Memorial Day 2027:
- The county study turns its camera data into findings on the left-turn options.
- The borough decides whether to hire a traffic engineer to look at the whole borough, as the chief recommended in July.
- The police department rents or buys a real-time message board.
- The state grant for the HAWK crossing moves forward.
The council meets through the off-season, and its agendas and minutes are posted on the borough's Agenda Center. The September meeting is where most of this update came from. Residents who sat in this summer's backups can follow the decisions there before next summer.
We've lived on this part of the island our whole lives. Ed grew up in Mantoloking, and Suzie in Bay Head. We follow what happens at the bridge as neighbors, not only as agents. If you have questions about how the bridge area and Barnegat Lane affect a particular street, or how a house near them shows during the summer, Edwin O'Malley and Suzie are happy to talk it through.