Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
An elegant cedar-shingle coastal home beyond pale dunes and dormant beach grass in soft winter afternoon light.

A Winter Listing in Mantoloking, Measured Against Last Year's Closings

November 19, 2026

On March 3, a 3,812-square-foot house at 982 Barnegat Lane changed hands for $7,850,000. When the deed was recorded later that month, it was the most expensive residential sale in Ocean County for the week of March 16-22. It closed weeks before beach season, in the middle of the off-season.

That sale was one of several. Over the past year, a run of Mantoloking's largest transactions closed between late December and the end of March. For an owner of a legacy or second home who is wondering whether to list now or wait for April, those closings show that Mantoloking's upper market kept producing sales through the winter, and at strong prices.

Seven Closings Between Christmas and the End of March

NJ.com publishes a weekly list of the ten most expensive homes sold in Ocean County. Each list counts sales by the week the title was recorded, even when the deal closed earlier. Prices in Mantoloking usually clear the cutoff, so the series works as a running log of the town's upper market. Mantoloking sales below a given week's tenth-place price do not show up in it.

From late December 2025 through March 2026, these Mantoloking closings appeared in the series:

Closing date Address Price Year built
Dec. 23, 2025 1318 Ocean Ave. $2,575,000 1910
Dec. 31, 2025 1097 Barnegat Lane $2,700,000 1967
Feb. 6, 2026 978 East Ave. $3,200,978 1937
March 3, 2026 982 Barnegat Lane $7,850,000 1983
March 13, 2026 920 East Ave. $4,500,000 1928
March 27, 2026 366 Highway 35 N $5,180,000 1987
March 31, 2026 506 Sunset Blvd. $5,250,000 2022

Together those seven sales come to a little over $31 million, and the middle price among them is $4.5 million. The NJ.com log also has five Mantoloking closings from April through early June. They ran from 1501 Ocean Ave. at $7,000,000 on April 7 to 308 Cove Drive at $1,770,000 on June 5, and the middle price was $3.3 million. Nine more closed between July 20 and Oct. 13, 2026, with a middle price of $3.6 million. That group includes 1325 Ocean Ave. at $8,550,000 on Sept. 14 and 176 Squan Beach Drive at $7,439,000 on Oct. 1.

Of the three groups, the December-through-March closings have the highest middle price, and they include the second-largest Mantoloking sale in the log. The two December closings, at 1318 Ocean Ave. on Dec. 23 and 1097 Barnegat Lane on Dec. 31, came in the last days of the year. The four March closings added up to $22.78 million in a single month.

The Houses That Sold in Winter Were Often the Older Ones

For families thinking about selling a long-held house, the ages of the winter sales matter. Three of the seven Mantoloking closings in that window were built before 1940: 1318 Ocean Ave. in 1910, 920 East Ave. in 1928 and 978 East Ave. in 1937.

The East Avenue sale stands out. NJ.com reported that 978 East Ave., a 2,190-square-foot house, sold for $3,200,978, which works out to $1,462 per square foot. That is a February price for a 1937 house. At 1318 Ocean Ave., the 1910 house sold for $764 per square foot over 3,370 square feet. The gap between those two figures is a reminder of how much location and lot matter in Mantoloking compared with the house itself. It is also a reminder that older houses found buyers at full shore prices while the town was in its off-season.

Newer construction sold in winter too. The 2022-built house at 506 Sunset Blvd. brought $5,250,000 on March 31, on 1,771 square feet. Winter buyers were not limited to one kind of house.

Fewer Listings Arrive in Winter Than Buyers Leave

The countywide numbers show why winter can favor a seller. New Jersey REALTORS® publishes monthly Ocean County reports on single-family homes. In January and February 2026, the county averaged 312 closings and 489.5 new listings a month. From March through June 2026, it averaged 429 closings and 790.25 new listings a month.

Both numbers fall in winter, but they fall by different amounts. New listings in January and February ran about 38 percent below the spring pace, while closings ran about 27 percent below it. Sellers step back from the market faster than buyers do. A house listed in January competes for a smaller pool of buyers, but it is also one of far fewer new listings that buyer is looking at.

The fall numbers add to this. The October 2026 Ocean County report counted 683 new single-family listings for the month, up 11.4 percent from October 2025, and 1,611 homes in inventory at month's end, up 8.6 percent. Months' supply was 3.7, up 15.6 percent from a year earlier. Countywide, more homes are reaching the market than a year ago. If that continues, a spring listing would compete with a larger group of houses than the same listing would have faced in the spring of 2026. Those are Ocean County figures, not Mantoloking's, and a Barnegat Lane bayfront does not compete directly with a starter home in Toms River. They still describe the conditions a buyer sees when deciding how quickly to act.

Bay Head's East Avenue Followed the Same Calendar

Next door, Bay Head's biggest sales fell into the same pattern. In the NJ.com list for Dec. 15-21, 2025, the top sale was a Bay Head house at 829 East Ave. It was a 1929 home with nine bedrooms and 6,023 square feet, and it sold for $11,500,000 on Dec. 2. On March 23, 750 East Ave., built in 1913, closed at $4,650,000. Bay Head's record sale of the year, 717 East Ave. at $16,000,000, closed on June 26.

Both towns are oceanfront communities with a summer focus, and old houses on East Avenue in both of them have sold at full prices outside of summer. Our Bay Head neighborhood page covers the local context.

What the Calendar Asks of a Seller This Winter

A Mantoloking owner who lists in December or January would be on the market during the same weeks that produced last winter's closings. That makes a few practical steps worth taking now rather than in March.

A buyer looking at a listing from New York, North Jersey or Philadelphia sees the photos first. Photos and drone footage taken during the summer show the beach, the bay and the porch the way the buyer will live with them. Those images need to be ready when the listing goes live, because in January the house cannot show itself in season. Tidying the grounds, servicing the heat and making sure a closed-up cottage is comfortable to tour in the cold also matter more in winter than in May.

Pricing is the other step. The sales above show that winter buyers in Mantoloking paid full shore prices, from $2,575,000 for a 1910 house on Ocean Avenue to $7,850,000 on Barnegat Lane. The town is also a group of distinct micro-markets, as our guide to Mantoloking's waterfront micro-markets explains. Price depends on which stretch of the borough a house is in and which water it faces, more than on any town-wide figure. Our Mantoloking neighborhood page brings that local picture together.

Waiting for spring is still a reasonable choice for some families. That is especially true when an estate needs time, several relatives have to agree, or a house needs work before it shows well. For a house that is ready now, last winter's record is seven Mantoloking closings between Dec. 23 and March 31, from $2,575,000 to $7,850,000.

If your family is weighing whether this winter or next spring is the right time to bring a Mantoloking house to market, Suzie & Ed, Diane Turton, REALTORS® will walk through the timing with you, street by street, using what has actually closed nearby. You can begin with a home valuation or simply contact us.

Follow Us On Instagram